Matty's Catering Menu

Buffets

All buffet pricing is for a minimum of 30 people. Pricing is subject to change based on market value.

Taste of Italy

Italian Meat Lasagna, Vegetable Lasagna, Chicken Marsala, Spaghetti with Meat Sauce or Meatballs, Chicken Parmigiana over light Pasta, Wild Mushroom Ravioli with Cream Sauce, Tortellini with Alfredo Sauce

Served with Side Choice of Garden or Classic Caesar Salad and Garlic Bread Sticks.

Choose 3: $26/person
Choose 2: $24/person
Choose 1: $22/person

Southern Classic BBQ

Choose Any 2: BBQ Shredded Chicken or Marinated Pulled Pork on Slider Rolls, Fried Chicken, Ribeye and Mushroom Sauce or Sliced Smoked Beef Brisket 

Choose Any 2: Homemade Baked Macaroni ‘n’ Cheese, Sweet Corn, Coleslaw, Potato Salad, Red Jacket Mashed Potatoes or Seasoned Baked Beans. Served with Corn Bread. 

$24/person

The Summer Grille Buffet

The Classic Grille Out is served with your choice of 2 types of meat plus Fresh Rolls, Assorted Cheese Slices, Fixins’ Tray, and Condiments.
Choose Any 2: 1/3# Burgers, Grilled Chicken Breasts, Usinger Brats, Italian Sausages, or Hot Dogs.
Choose Any 2: Potato Salad, Coleslaw, Pasta Salad, Baked Beans or Sweet Corn

$22/person

Taco Bar

Matty's Own Taco Bar includes Choice of 2 proteins: Adobo Pork, Cilantro Lime Chicken, Ground Beef, Tinga de Pollo, Steak or Shrimp Fajitas ($2/pp upcharge), Choice of 2 sides: Drunken Pinto Beans, Cilantro Lime Rice, Black Beans, Spanish Rice or Corn & Black Bean Salad.

Bars include Nacho Cheese Sauce, Corn & Flour Tortillas, Pico de Gallo, Corn & Bean Salsa, Fire Roasted Salsa, Tortilla Chips, and all the fixins!

Add On: Guacamole, Taco Dip, Cinnamon Sugar Tortilla Chips

$22/person

The Slider Bar

Choose Any 2: Shredded BBQ Chicken, Marinated Pulled Pork, Certified Black Angus Mini Burgers, or Petite Chicken Breasts.
Choose Any 2: Potato Salad, Italian Pasta Salad, or Coleslaw

Homemade chips included. Also Includes: Petite Rolls & appropriate Condiments & Fixins’

$18/person

Pizzeria Buffet

Includes our Family-Style Pizza, choice of Mostaccoli, Spaghetti or Macaroni & Cheese, choice of House, Caesar, Antipasto or Italian Chopped Salad and Garlic Bread

$18/person

Charcuterie & Trays

Wisconsin Charcuterie Board

Chef-selected cheeses, meats, fruit and crackers

$125 (Serves 40-50)

Dessert Board

Variety of sweets

$125 (Serves 40-50)

Breakfast Board

Breakfast assortment including hard-boiled eggs, bacon, pastries

$125 (Serves 40-50)

Fresh Seasonal Fruit Display

Beautiful colors paired with delicious seasonal fresh cut fruit

$95 (Serves 40-50)

Fresh Vegetable Display

A medley of fresh seasonal vegetables served with our house ranch dip and hummus

$95 (Serves 40-50)

Small Bites

Hot Appetizers

Minimum of 5 dozen or 5 lbs. per item

Spanakopita

Baby spinach mixed with Grecian feta cheese in a phyllo triangle

$22/dozen

Assorted Puff Pastries

Spinach/feta, roasted red pepper/parmesan, mushroom/ricotta cheese and four-cheese/jalapeno in puff pastry

$18/dozen

Beef Wellington

Beef tenderloin accented with mushroom duxelle and encased in a French style puff pastry

$51/dozen

Thai Chicken Spring Rolls

Tender chicken with lemongrass, ginger and green Thai chilis, wrapped with rice noodles and vegetables. Served with sweet & spicy sauce

$40/dozen

Cheese Steak Spring Rolls

Tender strips of marinated steak topped with melted cheese, loaded into a spring roll wrapper

$35/dozen

Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls

Fresh pulled white meat chicken topped with spicy buffalo sauce

$35/dozen

Wild Mushroom Tartlets

A savory handmade cup filled with a mix of wild mushrooms and artisan cheese

$38/dozen

Chicken Satay Skewers

A tender strip of skewered chicken with marinade

$33/dozen

Beef Sirloin Satay Skewers

Slice of skewered sirloin with marinade

$40/dozen

Crab Cakes

Crab cake coated with fresh breadcrumbs

$50/dozen

Bacon-Wrapped Scallops

Scallops wrapped in Applewood smoked bacon

$65/dozen

Beef Empanada

Southwest seasoned tender beef paired with fire roasted vegetables and black beans

$38/dozen

Chicken & Cheese Quesadilla

Tender chicken paired with cheddar and pepper jack cheeses,peppers and topped with salsa

$33/dozen

Beef Barbacoa Taquito

Onions, fresh lime, cilantro & spices rolled into a mini seasoned taquito

$40/dozen

Impossible Beef Fajita Style Quesadilla

Impossible Beef with spices, sauteed vegetables and melted plant based cheese in a tortilla

$41/dozen

Mini Cuban Sandwich

Shredded pork, pickle relish, smoked ham and swiss cheese on petite bread

$48/dozen

Raspberry & Brie in Phyllo Roll

Flaky phyllo roll filled with brie cheese, raspberry preserves and toasted almonds

$45/dozen

Pear & Brie in Phyllo Roll

Flaky phyllo roll filled with creamy brie cheese, pear puree and toasted almonds

$44/dozen

Handmade Meatballs

Choice of Swedish, Italian, Bourbon, BBQ

$14/lb

Bacon-Wrapped Bratwurst

Usinger’s Brat pieces wrapped in Usinger’s bacon

$20/dozen

Stuffed Mushrooms

Crab stuffed $24/dozen
Garlic Cream Cheese $20/dozen

Matty’s Boneless Wings

Choice of Sauces: Buffalo, Teriyaki, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan
Served with choice of ranch or bleu cheese and celery sticks

$11/pound

Matty’s Homemade Spinach ‘n’ Artichoke Dip

Served with freshly fried tortilla chips

$12/lb

Cold Appetizers

Minimum of 5 dozen or 5 lbs. per item

Pesto Bruschetta

Toasted baguette brushed with a cream cheese pesto and sprinkled with shredded parmesan

$16/dozen

Original Bruschetta

Toasted baguette topped with fresh basil, mozzarella, and plum tomatoes

$17/dozen

Jumbo Iced Shrimp

Served cold with cocktail sauce

$28/dozen

Veggie Caprese Skewer

Tomato, mozzarella pearl, and fresh basil

$18/dozen

Cold Tortilla Roll-Ups

An assortment of smoked ham, peppered turkey, roast beef, or veggie wrapped in a flavored tortilla shell

$16/dozen

Deviled Eggs

$18/dozen

Assorted Silver Dollar Sandwiches

These may include roast beef, smoked ham, or peppered turkey with lettuce and tomatoes on assorted rolls

$45/dozen

Matty's Homemade Chips

$35

French Onion Dip

Pairs deliciously with Matty’s Homemade Potato Chips

$6/lb

Sandwiches and Wraps

Matty's Classic Box

Ham and Swiss
Deli-style ham and swiss cheese | lettuce | tomato | dijonnaise on assorted rolls

Turkey and Monterey Jack
Deli-style turkey and monterey jack cheese | lettuce| tomato | parmesan peppercorn on assorted rolls

Roast Beef and Provolone
Roast Beef and provolone | lettuce | tomato | garlic mayo on assorted rolls

Italian
Ham| salami | provolone | lettuce| tomato |seasoned olive oil on assorted rolls

BLT
Bacon|lettuce|tomato|mayo on assorted rolls

Club
Turkey | bacon | ham| monterey jack | lettuce|tomato| mayo on assorted rolls

Chicken Salad
Chicken Salad | lettuce | tomato on assorted rolls

Veggie Caprese
Fresh mozzarella | tomato | lettuce|pesto on assorted rolls

**Choice of roll or wrap (Full Box Only)

$125/ Box (24 Assorted Sandwich halves, wrapped, served open-faced | Choose up to 5 varieties)

Individual Box Lunch

Includes sandwich/wrap choice from Matty's Classic Box plus chips and a cookie

$14.50

Assorted Silver Dollar Sandwiches

Assortment includes ham, turkey or roast beef plus lettuce and tomato on slider rolls

$45/dozen

Salads and Soups

Salads serve approximately 25-35 people

Summer Picnic Salad 

Spinach and romaine leaves tossed with pecans, blueberries, strawberries and Parmesan cheese. Served with Raspberry Vinaigrette

$60

Roasted Chicken Salad

Slow roasted chicken on spinach and romaine tossed with sundried tomatoes, mushrooms, red onions, garlic croutons and shaved parmesan cheese. Served with Italian Vinaigrette.

$60

Italian Chopped Salad

A blend of romaine and spinach tossed with chopped cucumbers, red onions, black olives, pepperoni, salami and feta cheese. Served with Balsamic Vinaigrette.

$60

Grilled Chicken Harvest Salad

A blend of romaine and spinach tossed with grapes, apples, bleu cheese crumbles, grilled chicken and walnuts. Served with Raspberry Vinaigrette.

$60

Executive Chef Salad

Julienne smoked ham, peppered turkey, swiss and cheddar cheese, tomatoes,cucumbers,peppers, sliced egg and croutons over greens. Served with Ranch or Italian Dressing

$60

House Salad

A combination of seasonal greens tossed with tomatoes,cucumbers,mushrooms,croutons and shredded parmesan. Served with Ranch or Italian Dressing

$40

Classic Caesar

Hearts of romaine tossed with shredded parmesan and garlic croutons. Served with our signature Caesar Dressing

$45

Potato Salad 

$6.50/lb

Italian Pasta Salad

$10/lb

Coleslaw

$10/lb

Jack Daniels Signature Chili (Seasonal)

Served with cheddar cheese, diced onions, sour cream and crackers

$65/gallon (16-8oz portions)

Desserts

Dessert Board

Variety of Sweets

$125 (Serves 40-50)

Cake Balls

Flavors: Chocolate, Lemon, Birthday Cake

$18/dozen (minimum 5 dozen)

Assorted Cheesecake Slices

$30/dozen

Chocolate Brownies

Traditional and delicious

$24/dozen

Mini Creme Puffs

$22/dozen (minimum 5 dozen)

Mini Eclairs

$22/dozen (minimum 5 dozen)

Petits Fours

$26/dozen (minimum 5 dozen)

Breakfast Catering

Egg Bakes & Scrambles

Serves 40

Wisconsin 3 Cheese Egg Bake

$95

Ham & 3 Cheese Blend

$105

Sausage & 3 Cheese Blend

$105

Denver - Ham, Onion, Pepper, Cheese

$105

Farmhouse - Hashbrowns, Cheese, Ham, Onion

$105

Veggie - Spinach, Tomato, Mushroom & 3 Cheese Blend

$95

Scrambled Eggs

$95

Potatoes

Serves 40

Breakfast Potatoes with Peppers & Onions

$95

Hashbrowns

$80

Meats

By the pound

Breakfast Sausage

$11/lb

Bacon

$15/lb

Breads

Pancakes with Butter & Syrup

$12/lb

French Toast Sticks with Butter & Syrup

$15/lb

Bagels

Sweet or Savory

$20/dozen

Croissants

$18/dozen

Pastries

Breakfast Board

Assortment including pastries, hard-boiled eggs, salami & bacon

$125

Assorted Mini Muffins

Blueberry, Cinnamon, Chocolate

$15/dozen

Assorted Mini Danish

Cinnamon, Apple, Raspberry, Vanilla, Maple Pecan

$21/dozen

Beverages

Coffee by the Box

Serves 20

$25

Orange Juice by the Gallon

Serves 20

$25